December 10, 2003

Pretend Percy?

Downstairs in the lobby of the Medical Mall, there's some kind of Christmas Open Housepital, with lots of eggnog and people in wheelchairs. I just rode the elevator back up to my eighth-floor office with my plate piled full of little Swedish meatballs covered in what tastes like barbecue sauce. Ah, the South.

Speaking of which, there's a fascinating article in the New Republic critiquing the critical cliche that Bruce Springsteen is the spokesman for everyday American workers. David Hajdu argues that Springsteen may speak for what many Americans want to be (tought, tender, irrepressible), but that he rarely if ever speaks for himself, which makes him an odd figure to embrace for his authenticity.

But what's really incendiary is Hadju's thinly veiled accusation that Harvard professor Robert Coles fabricated many of the quotes in his book about Springsteen, including pages of quotes supposedly from the aging Walker Percy. As a Percy and Springsteen fan, I knew that the southern novelist had sent the Jersey rock star a rather intellectual fan letter in the late 1980s, and that Springsteen had spoken well of Percy in interviews. But I knew nothing of the Percy quotes -- if they are that -- in Coles' book.

I have no idea whether Coles cooked up the quotes or not. But they certainly don't sound like Percy: "This guy is his own boss--he's earned the title every inch of the way: he sings of us while singing to us, and what you hear (the one you're hearing) is a plain, ordinary guy soaring way above himself and everyone around him through his voice, and through the songs he's written."

percy.jpg

This is rambling claptrap, nothing like Percy's usual withdrawn, sadonic quality in oral interviews. High praise from Percy usually was limited to the suggestion that the person in question wasn't a complete rat-bastard. It's always possible that my favorite writer accidentally slipped into cheerful charity (maybe he hadn't had his whiskey yet), but I certainly hope not. Now I'm annoyed, and not even the little chicken wings from downstairs are helping.

Posted by mesh at December 10, 2003 04:44 PM | TrackBack
Comments

When I moved to New Orleans to help with a church plant for the PCA, Will Percy (Walker's "favorite nephew," according to Will) had become friends with my brother-in-law (the pastor of that church plant). Percy drove me around one day to help me find an apartment, and he mentioned that he had in the not too distant past interviewed Springsteen for a magazine. He made it seem like Springsteen and Percy had some kind of brief correspondence, but that they never were able to meet. I think that Walker Percy helped grease the wheels for Will to get the interview though, because if I remember correctly, there was some kind of note that Walker wrote Bruce, mentioning Will as his "favorite nephew," or some business like that, and that Walker was interested in Bruce's spiritual pilgramage as evidenced in his song lyrics. I bet if you could get Will's email address, he could substantiate whether the quotes are fabricated or not. He quit going to our church, but I might be able to find out more by asking my brother-in-law for his email address and ask him whether those quotes were true or not. I'll see what I can dig up.

Posted by: scott cunningham at December 11, 2003 10:48 AM

Okay, I just read the article. That's the way Will told it. It was one letter that Walker wrote Springsteen mentioning interest in Bruce's spiritual journey, and that Bruce had not attended to the letter until after Walker had died.

Posted by: scott cunningham at December 11, 2003 10:52 AM

Coles' quotes still sound fishy to me -- they don't fit Percy's speaking patterns in other interviews, and while I don't doubt Percy admired Springsteen, even to that raving extent, I just can't see him talking about it in such silly terms.

Posted by: mesh at December 11, 2003 11:27 AM

Yeah, I agree with that. He sounds like a Rolling Stone writer in those quotes. How did Cole say he got those quotes anyway?

Posted by: scott cunningham at December 11, 2003 01:34 PM

I don't know. I'd have to see a copy of Coles' book. If the conversation did happen, I would assume it took place on Percy's porch, where he conducted most conversations in his later years. My gut feeling on this isn't that Coles constructed fake quotes out of cold cloth, but that he's the sort of reporter with a boomerang ear -- it's like a tin ear, only instead of all his sources sounding forced and awkward, they sound forced, awkward and exactly like Robert Coles. All his sources come back to what he was thinking in the first place. I've been guilty of this in some reporting, but it seems pretty weak for a Harvard prof. Plus he's messing with Percy. Which ticks me off.

By the way, Scott, have you had a chance to look at Paul Elie's excellent biography of Percy, Flan O'Connor, Thomas Merton and Dorothy Day, "The Life You Save May Be Your Own"? That's where I first read about Percy's interest in the Boss. I think you'd really dig that book.

Posted by: mesh at December 11, 2003 03:07 PM

Thanks for the rec, Mesh. It's going on the Christmas wish list asap. I've not heard of it, but that sounds like a fascinating read.

Posted by: scott cunningham at December 12, 2003 12:37 PM

A quadruple biography of my favorite 20-cent. Catholics? Have I died and gone to heaven already?

Yeah, and those quotes do seem tacky. The syntax is all f***ed up for one thing. I've only read one Percy book, but I did get the impression that he knew how to write/speak.

Posted by: Evan Donovan at December 13, 2003 04:37 PM

Would you mind doing me a favor? Would you go here and let me know if you have any insights? Thanks.

http://puravida.typepad.com/only_connect/2004/01/the_search.html

Posted by: Trey at January 24, 2004 10:58 AM

When I was trying to find an apartment a little while ago, I found this sublease auction site. They have apartment listings for sublease that you can bid on. I bid on one of the sublease auctions and got my place for a third of what my neighbor pays for the same unit. Check them out - http://www.subleaseauction.com Good luck with your search.

Posted by: sublease auction at February 21, 2005 11:32 PM
Post a comment









Remember personal info?